top of page

Fix Your NAP Consistency, Fix Your Rankings

8 min read

What the Hell is NAP and Why Should You Care?

Let's cut through the marketing BS right away. NAP stands for Name, Address, and Phone Number. Simple, right? But here's what most "experts" won't tell you: inconsistent NAP information across the web is probably the silent killer destroying your local search rankings and costing you real customers every single day.


Think about it. If Google sees your business listed as "Joe's Plumbing" on your website, "Joe's Plumbing Services" on Yelp, and "Joe's Plumbing & Heating" on Facebook—with slightly different addresses or phone numbers—how is it supposed to know these are all the same business?


The brutal truth: Google doesn't know. And when Google's confused, you don't show up in search results. Period.

Fix Your NAP Consistency, Fix Your Rankings - KaeRae Marketing

The Real-World Cost of NAP Inconsistency

Let these numbers sink in:

  • Businesses with inconsistent NAP information lose an average of 13% of their annual revenue

  • 43% of businesses have at least one incorrect or missing NAP listing online

  • 73% of consumers lose trust in businesses with incorrect business listings

  • Local businesses with consistent NAP data receive 23% more website clicks from Google than those with inconsistencies

  • 68% of consumers would stop using a local business if they found incorrect information online


Bottom line: NAP inconsistency isn't just some technical SEO issue—it's literally sending customers to your competitors and destroying trust in your business.


How NAP Consistency Actually Impacts Your Business

Before we dive into fixing the problem, let's understand exactly how NAP consistency affects your local business visibility:


1. It Determines If You Show Up in Google's Local Pack

The coveted "Local Pack" (those three business listings with the map at the top of search results) heavily weights NAP consistency in its ranking algorithm.


Fact: A case study by BrightLocal found that fixing NAP inconsistencies alone resulted in a 23% increase in Local Pack appearances within 30 days.


2. It Impacts Your Google Business Profile Visibility

Your Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business) is the cornerstone of your local search presence. When NAP details don't match across the web, Google's trust in your profile decreases.


Eye-Opening Stat: Businesses with consistent NAP information across the web receive 25% more clicks on their Google Business Profile than those with inconsistencies.


3. It Affects Customer Trust and Conversion Rates

Beyond the technical SEO impact, inconsistent information frustrates potential customers.


Real-World Example: Mike's Auto Shop in Denver had incorrect phone numbers listed on three major directories. Using call tracking, they discovered they were missing approximately 15 calls per week from customers who found the wrong number. At an average service value of $210, this was costing them over $3,000 weekly in lost business.


4. It Determines Voice Search Success

With 58% of consumers now using voice search to find local business information, NAP consistency has become even more critical.


Key Insight: Voice search systems like Siri, Alexa, and Google Assistant rely heavily on consistent NAP data to provide answers. If your information is inconsistent, you simply won't be recommended.


The 7 Most Common NAP Mistakes That Are Killing Your Business

Before we fix the problem, let's identify the most common NAP consistency mistakes:


Mistake #1: Abbreviations vs. Spelled-Out Words

  • Bad Example: "123 Main St." on your website but "123 Main Street" on directories

  • Impact: Google sees these as two different addresses


Mistake #2: Business Name Variations

  • Bad Example: "Premier Plumbing Solutions" vs. "Premier Plumbing" vs. "Premier Plumbing & Heating"

  • Impact: Each variation is treated as a separate business


Mistake #3: Suite/Unit Number Inconsistencies

  • Bad Example: "Suite 100" vs. "#100" vs. "Ste 100" vs. not including it at all

  • Impact: Creates confusion about your exact location


Mistake #4: Phone Number Formatting Differences

  • Bad Example: (555) 123-4567 vs. 555-123-4567 vs. 5551234567

  • Impact: These are seen as different contact points


Mistake #5: Tracking Numbers Gone Wrong

  • Bad Example: Using different tracking phone numbers across platforms

  • Impact: Destroys NAP consistency and confuses search engines


Mistake #6: Old Locations Never Updated

  • Bad Example: After moving, failing to update all online listings

  • Impact: Customers go to the wrong location and leave angry reviews


Mistake #7: Local vs. Toll-Free Number Inconsistency

  • Bad Example: Using your local number on some platforms and your 800 number on others

  • Impact: Creates confusion about which is your primary contact method


The Complete NAP Consistency Audit and Cleanup System

Now that you understand why NAP consistency matters, let's fix it. Follow this step-by-step system to audit and correct your NAP information across the web:


Step 1: Establish Your Canonical NAP Format

First, decide on the EXACT format for your business information that you'll use everywhere moving forward.


Your Canonical NAP Checklist:

  • Business Name: Decide on one official version (with or without LLC, Inc., etc.)

  • Address: Choose one format (St. vs. Street, Ave. vs. Avenue)

  • Suite/Unit Format: Pick one style (Suite 100, #100, Ste 100)

  • City, State, ZIP: Use consistent capitalization and formatting

  • Phone: Choose one format with or without parentheses and consistent spacing

  • Website URL: With or without www, with or without trailing slash


Example Canonical NAP:

Premier Plumbing Solutions

123 Main Street, Suite 100

Denver, CO 80202

(303) 555-7890


Pro Tip: Create a simple document with your canonical NAP information and share it with everyone in your company. Make it the standard for any online listing, business card, or marketing material.


Step 2: Conduct a Comprehensive NAP Audit

Now that you know what your information SHOULD be, find out where it's wrong.


DIY Audit Method:

  1. Google your business phone number in quotes (e.g., "303-555-7890")

    • Check every result on the first 3 pages

    • Note any inconsistencies

  2. Google your business name + city

    • Review the first 5 pages of results

    • Document every variation you find

  3. Check these critical platforms manually:

    • Google Business Profile

    • Yelp

    • Facebook

    • Better Business Bureau

    • Apple Maps

    • Bing Places

    • Your website (check header, footer, contact page, and schema markup)


Tool-Based Audit (Faster Method): Use a tool like Moz Local, BrightLocal, or Semrush to run a citation audit. These tools typically cost $15-50 for a one-time scan and will find inconsistencies automatically.


Step 3: Prioritize Your Cleanup Efforts

Not all NAP inconsistencies hurt equally. Focus your efforts in this order:

Tier 1 (Fix Immediately):

  • Google Business Profile

  • Your website

  • Facebook Business Page

  • Apple Maps

  • Yelp

  • Industry-specific directories (e.g., Healthgrades for doctors, Avvo for lawyers)


Tier 2 (Fix Within 30 Days):

  • Bing Places

  • Better Business Bureau

  • YellowPages

  • Local Chamber of Commerce

  • Major data aggregators (Infogroup, Acxiom, Localeze, Factual)


Tier 3 (Fix When Possible):

  • Smaller industry directories

  • Social media profiles

  • Older listings


Step 4: Implement the Cleanup Process

Now comes the actual work. There are three approaches to fixing NAP inconsistencies:


DIY Approach (Free But Time-Consuming):

  1. Create an account on each platform where you found inconsistencies

  2. Claim your business listing if you haven't already

  3. Update the information to match your canonical NAP

  4. Keep a spreadsheet tracking what you've updated and login credentials


Semi-Automated Approach (Moderate Cost): Use a service like BrightLocal, Moz Local, or Yext that allows you to update multiple listings from one dashboard.

  • Cost: $15-70/month

  • Time saved: Approximately 10-15 hours per location


Full-Service Approach (Highest Cost): Hire an agency to handle everything.

  • Cost: $500-1,500 one-time fee

  • Time saved: 15-25 hours per location


Real-World Example: Sarah's Bakery in Chicago had inconsistent NAP data across 27 different websites. Using the semi-automated approach with BrightLocal, she corrected 22 of these in one afternoon at a cost of $39. Within 45 days, her Google Business Profile views increased by 36%, and direction requests increased by 24%.


Step 5: Prevent Future Inconsistencies

Once you've cleaned up your NAP, prevent new problems with these proactive measures:


Internal NAP Management:

  1. Create a company-wide NAP document that everyone references

  2. Add NAP updates to your moving/relocation checklist

  3. Assign one person to be responsible for NAP consistency


Technical Prevention:

  1. Use Schema markup on your website (code sample below)

  2. Create a central "Store Locator" or "Contact Us" page on your site

  3. Set up Google Alerts for your business name to monitor for unauthorized listings


Schema Markup Example (for developers or website managers):

<script type="application/ld+json">

{

  "@context": "https://schema.org",

  "@type": "LocalBusiness",

  "name": "Premier Plumbing Solutions",

  "address": {

    "@type": "PostalAddress",

    "streetAddress": "123 Main Street, Suite 100",

    "addressLocality": "Denver",

    "addressRegion": "CO",

    "postalCode": "80202",

    "addressCountry": "US"

  },

  "telephone": "(303) 555-7890",

}

</script>


Tracking the Impact of Your NAP Cleanup

How do you know if your NAP consistency efforts are working? Monitor these metrics:


1. Google Business Profile Insights

  • Views of your business profile

  • Website clicks from your profile

  • Direction requests

  • Phone calls


2. Local Search Rankings

  • Position in Google's Local Pack

  • Google Maps ranking position

  • Organic search rankings for "[service] + [location]" terms


3. Website Analytics

  • Local organic traffic (filter by city/region)

  • Branded search traffic (people searching your business name)

  • Conversion rates from local traffic


Pro Tip: Take screenshots of your metrics before starting your NAP cleanup process so you can document improvements.


Addressing Common NAP Questions and Special Situations

Let's tackle some specific situations that might apply to your business:


"I've Changed My Business Name. What Do I Do?"

  1. Update your highest priority listings first (Google Business Profile, website, Facebook)

  2. Consider running both names together temporarily on your website: "Premier Plumbing (Formerly ABC Plumbing)"

  3. Create a redirect from any old domain names to your current website

  4. Be patient—it typically takes 3-6 months for all traces of your old name to be updated in Google's database


"We've Moved Locations. How Do We Handle This?"

  1. Update your Google Business Profile immediately with the new address

  2. Do NOT create a new Google Business Profile—update the existing one

  3. Add a notice to your website announcing the move

  4. Update your schema markup with both your current and previous address (for 3-6 months)

  5. Prioritize updating major directories over minor ones


"We Have Multiple Locations. How Do We Maintain NAP Consistency?"

  1. Create a separate Google Business Profile for each location

  2. Use location-specific phone numbers, not a central call center number

  3. Create individual location pages on your website with unique content for each

  4. Use schema markup with multiple location entries

  5. Consider a specialized multi-location citation service like Moz Local


"We're a Service Area Business Without a Physical Location Customers Visit. What Should We Do?"

  1. Use your actual business address on Google Business Profile but select "I deliver goods and services to my customers"

  2. Define your service area by cities or zip codes, not radius

  3. Use a consistent phone number across all platforms

  4. If you work from home and have privacy concerns, consider a virtual office address


The Big Picture: NAP Consistency as Part of Your Local SEO Strategy

NAP consistency is foundational, but it works best as part of a comprehensive local SEO approach:


The Local SEO Pyramid:

  1. Foundation: NAP Consistency (what we've covered here)

  2. Structure: Optimized Google Business Profile (categories, attributes, posts)

  3. Walls: Website Optimization (local content, mobile-friendly design)

  4. Roof: Reviews and Reputation (quantity, quality, responses)

  5. Solar Panels: Ongoing Content and Engagement (posts, Q&A, photos)


By fixing your NAP consistency, you're building a solid foundation for all your other local marketing efforts.


Your 30-Day NAP Consistency Action Plan

Don't get overwhelmed—follow this step-by-step plan:


Week 1: Audit and Planning

  • Day 1-2: Establish your canonical NAP format

  • Day 3-5: Conduct your NAP audit (manual or using tools)

  • Day 6-7: Prioritize your listings and create a cleanup schedule


Week 2: High-Priority Fixes

  • Day 8-9: Update your website NAP information

  • Day 10: Update Google Business Profile

  • Day 11-12: Update Facebook, Yelp, and Apple Maps

  • Day 13-14: Update industry-specific directories


Week 3: Second-Tier Fixes

  • Day 15-16: Update data aggregators (Infogroup, Acxiom, etc.)

  • Day 17-18: Update Bing Places and Better Business Bureau

  • Day 19-21: Update remaining major directories


Week 4: Prevention and Tracking

  • Day 22-23: Implement schema markup on your website

  • Day 24-25: Create your NAP management system

  • Day 26-28: Document all login credentials for future updates

  • Day 29-30: Set up tracking to monitor improvements


The Bottom Line: NAP Consistency is Not Sexy, But It Works

Let's be honest—fixing NAP consistency isn't the most exciting marketing task. It's detailed, sometimes tedious work. But the ROI can be massive for local businesses.


Consider this real case study:

Johnson's Heating & Cooling in Atlanta had severe NAP inconsistencies across the web. After a systematic cleanup using the exact process outlined in this guide, they saw:

  • 41% increase in Google Business Profile views

  • 27% increase in website traffic from local searches

  • 19% increase in phone calls from Google

  • 15% reduction in "Where are you located?" calls


The best part? The entire process cost them less than $200 in tools and about 12 hours of work spread over a month.


NAP consistency might not be sexy, but it's one of the highest-ROI activities any local business can undertake.

Comments

bottom of page